| |
10 Lessons Learned from 3 professional mixes
For the three new tracks that will appear on 20 Greatest, I decided to take the mixing and mastering out of my own hands - and over to the professionals. By professionals, we mean people who actually do this for their living - and get their primary income from mixing and mastering. In general, it is obviously good to rely on professionals. If you have a water leak in your house - get a plumber and do it properly. No different with music - although - there are some pre-requisites, that I think you have to consider before you bring in the professionals. In this article I will talk abit about that. But I will focus mainly on what I learned from having my 3 songs mixed and mastered by the professionals.

Three new tracks "Girl Crush", "Rock and Roll Time" and "One More Teardrop" was produced at The Fluffy Jackets Sound Studio, produced by Helge Rognstad, prepared specifically for the 20 Greatest (2007-2027) compilation album. The mix-job was completed in Los Angeles by Grammy-nominated engineer Ryan Nasci, whose credits include Harry Styles, Katy Perry, and Christone “Kingfish” Ingram. The tracks were mastered in Oxford UK by Tim Turan who is a highly experienced mastering engineer who has worked on more than 24,000 records, with notable credits including Nazareth, Supergrass, Madness, Thin Lizzy, Status Quo and Killing Joke.
Background: why these particular songs & why approaching professional people?
First off, I knew that the three songs I sent for mixing were well-written and good quality songs. Yes, they are cover versions but in this particular exercise I see that as an advantage, because the songs have already been proven successful. They have proven themselves to work with an actual audience. With an original song, there is an unavoidable uncertainty: you may think the song is great, but at the point of recording it you have no way of knowing whether anyone else will agree with you. With these three particular songs that question had already been answered positively, which means that the mixer would not face that particular hurdle (because a great mix cannot rescue a weak song).
Secondly, I had spent alot of time recording these songs, so I knew the performances inside out. I knew the strengths and weaknesses of the recordings. I knew which tracks would require more work than others, which parts were likely to be difficult to mix. It would therefore be interesting to see which path a professional mixer would go. For example: I have four guitars on one track - and I absolutely love each one - if I take one out, the track feels naked without it. At the same time I know that having them all the time in the song would make the song feel "too samey". So, familiarity can be useful, but it can also make objective decisions harder. After spending enough time with a recording, it is easy to become attached to individual sounds and performances, even when they may not be serving the finished track (aka "demoities" may come into play).
The real value of this whole exercise, then, isn’t simply in having someone else make the mixes sound better. It’s in stepping back and asking why those decisions were made, what I might have done differently with the recordings, and what I can learn from the process. If I can take those observations and turn them into a few broader principles for my own recording, production and mixing, then the experience becomes much more valuable than simply paying for a professional result.
What advice was given to the mixer and mastering engineer from me?
Before looking at the “lessons learned”, it is worth clarifying the brief given to the mixer and mastering engineer, as this inevitably influenced the outcome.
Since one of the main reasons for using outside professionals was to preserve objectivity, I deliberately kept the instructions to the mixer to the bare minimum. I did not want to tell someone with fresh ears how I thought every instrument should sound or where every element should sit. Instead, the brief was essentially to mix with emotion and purpose, and not be afraid to make bold choices if they served the song. All the tracks were sent completely dry - without any effects - as I wanted the mixer to respond to the music rather than simply execute a list of instructions from me. However, I did sent a rough mix - just to help the mixer get an idea of the overall production.
The mastering brief was somewhat more specific. My main request was to avoid excessive compression and the temptation to make the tracks unnecessarily loud. These are blues-based recordings, and I wanted to preserve the organic, natural character of the performances and instruments. Therefore, sonically, I asked the mastering engineer to get closer to records such as Jimmy Rogers’ Blues Blues Blues and Muddy Waters’ Hard Again — records that sound great in terms of dynamics and character rather than sounding overly processed.

Celebrating 20 years and 20 songs, The Fluffy Jackets' 20 Greatest (2007-2027) brings together highlights from the band’s career while looking ahead to the next chapter, featuring three brand new tracks mixed in Los Angeles by Grammy-nominated engineer Ryan Nasci and mastering engineer Tim Turan.
The lessons learned
I should preface this content by saying the advice below does not represents the actual words, opinions or thoughts of the mixer or mastering engineer: These are observations I made and these are my own conclusions (unless otherwise stated); drawn from listening closely to the decisions made in the mixes and masters - the actual audio files - I received back. Thus, the opinions are based on my ears - not theirs.
1. The song comes first
Actually - the first lesson is something I have learned before - but it is a lesson always worth remembering. It brought me back to something I was told years ago by Manny Charlton (Nazareth): first you need a good song, then a good performance, and finally a good production and recording.
With Girl Crush, we had a strong song and strong performances from Alison, Matt Bradford, Neil Murray, Matija Bajtal and myself. More importantly, everyone was playing for the song rather than trying to demonstrate what they could do individually. I believed in the song, the performance - and now I needed a good end-sound, which is why I selected this song as one of the three tracks to be mixed externally. The reason I say this is because a great mix can not fix a weak song and a great recording can not rescue a poor performance:
Key lessons:
-
A great mix cannot rescue a weak song.
-
A great recording cannot rescue a poor performance.
-
Good musicians play for the song.
-
Production starts with the writing, arrangement and performance.
2. The record starts before the mix
One of the earliest lessons came from a conversation with Massimo at AIR Studios in London about Girl Crush. His advice was to use live drums on this particular track, because the human element would bring more dynamics and movement. It also made me think more carefully about how a song develops from beginning to end - and to pay attention to each little detail. A performance obviously doesn't need to remain identical throughout. Verses, choruses and later sections should be allowed to develop naturally. Sometimes that means adding something; sometimes it means taking something away. Sometimes that means recording drums 3-4 times (like we did on this recording)
Key lessons:
-
Build dynamics into the arrangement and performance.
-
Use live musicians where the human element adds something important.
-
Fix problems at the recording stage where possible rather than relying on the mix.
3. Put the vocal at the centre
Ryan's mix made it very clear that the vocal was the priority. It was loud enough and clear enough to carry the story, without sounding disconnected from the rest of the track.
The instruments around it supported what the singer was doing rather than competing with it. This applies particularly to guitars: they can sound great on their own but still be wrong for the mix if they get in the way of the vocal.
Key lessons:
-
The vocal needs to communicate the story.
-
Don't let instruments compete with the important words.
-
EQ and level should support the vocal rather than simply making it louder.
-
Listen to the relationship between the vocal and the arrangement.
4. Make every instrument sound good
One of the things I noticed immediately was how clearly the individual instruments could be heard. Each had its own place, but each also sounded like a good version of itself.
It is easy to get distracted by technical decisions when mixing — EQ curves, compressors, saturation and plug-ins. Ryan's mix reminded me that the most basic question is still the most important one: does the instrument actually sound good?
Key lessons:
-
Make each instrument sound good before worrying about complicated processing.
-
Give competing instruments their own space.
-
Don't process something simply because you can.
-
Listen to the sound rather than concentrating on the plug-in.
5. Mix with a purpose
A professional mix isn't necessarily about finding a place for every recorded track. Some parts may be useful during recording but unnecessary in the finished arrangement.
The important question is whether a part contributes to the song. If it doesn't help the story, the emotion or the groove, it may be better turned down or removed altogether. The hard thing is to identify what part should go, which part does not add to the story?
Key lessons:
-
Every part should have a reason for being there.
-
Don't be afraid to mute or remove something you recorded.
-
Less can sometimes make the important elements more effective.
-
Don't mix the session — mix the song.
6. Create dynamics through contrast
The difference between the various sections of the songs was another important lesson. A chorus doesn't necessarily become bigger by simply adding more instruments or turning everything up.
Sometimes the best way to make a chorus work is to make the section before it smaller. Removing instrumentation from a verse creates space for the chorus to arrive with greater impact.
Key lessons:
-
Think about the relationship between sections.
-
Make verses smaller if the chorus needs to feel bigger.
-
Don't automatically add more when something needs more impact.
-
Use contrast to create energy.
7. Don't be afraid of the fader
There are movement in the mixes. Small fader adjustments helped individual parts appear when they were needed and disappear when they weren't.
This is something that can easily be overlooked when working in a DAW. It is tempting to set levels, get everything sounding balanced and leave the faders alone. But a song changes emotionally from section to section, so the mix needs to change with it.
Key lessons:
-
Use level changes to follow the emotion of the song.
-
Small fader movements can make a big musical difference.
-
Don't be afraid to automate individual words, phrases or instruments.
8. Give the drums space
The treatment of the drums was another useful lesson. Panning was used to give the individual elements their own space and to make the kit work within the wider arrangement - and that way you clearly can hear the drums as well.
This wasn't about following a fixed panning formula. The decisions were made in relation to the rest of the track and what needed to stand out at any particular moment.
Key lessons:
-
Use panning to create space and clarity.
-
Don't treat every mix according to the same formula.
-
Listen to the drums in the context of the whole arrangement.
-
Make the elements that matter most easy to hear.
9. Mastering finishes a good mix
Once the mixes were finished, the tracks were mastered by Tim Turan. Hearing the final masters provided another useful reference point. The tracks now had the final consistency, polish and level required to sit alongside other professionally released recordings. Importantly, this final stage allows the song to compete with other songs on the radio.
The mix needs to work before it reaches the mastering engineer - and the mastering engineer needs headroom to work. Mastering is the final stage of getting the best possible result from a good recording and mix.
Key lessons:
-
Get the mix right before worrying about mastering.
-
Don't expect mastering to fix fundamental mix problems.
-
Use mastering as the final stage rather than another mix stage.
-
A good master starts with a good song, performance, recording and mix.
10. What I take forward
The biggest lesson from the whole process is that production is largely about making good decisions. The equipment and software are important tools, but they don't replace the decisions made about the song, arrangement, performances, sounds, levels and dynamics. Having three tracks professionally mixed has also given me something useful to take back into my own studio:
What to take forward:
-
Add these 3 tracks as reference mixes - in my own mixing template.
-
Listen critically to the decisions - what was brought forward, what was removed, where the dynamics were created and why certain parts were given more or less space.

Celebrating 20 years and 20 songs, The Fluffy Jackets' 20 Greatest (2007-2027) brings together highlights from the band’s career while looking ahead to the next chapter, featuring three brand new tracks mixed in Los Angeles by Grammy-nominated engineer Ryan Nasci and Mastered by Tim Turan.
|
|